Nietzsches final section of the book devoted to the matter of discipline and breeding outlines nietzsches idea of the eternal recurrence and how this must be faced by th. No one would really know or confirm if particular things or event shad already happened in the past and just recurring. Eternal return is a theory that the universe and all existence and energy. Time and personal identity in nietzsches theory of eternal. Mar 06, 2018 nietzsche was pretty invested in this question, which he called eternal recurrence, or eternal return. Nietzsches philosophy of the eternal recurrence of the same. The eternal recurrence of the same martin heidegger on amazon. The eternal return quotes share book recommendations. Nietzsche the eternal recurrence of the same download. It offers formulations of eternal recurrence, and nietzsche for the first time speaks of the ubermensch. I will forgo the temptation to summarize zdm, for taken together their essays effectively outline the book s main lines of argument. That eternal recurrence is a consequence of the will to power may be plausible as regards the structure of zarathustra, but it is false as regards the actual development of nietzsches thought, for nietzsche embraced eternal recurrence before he developed the idea of the will to power found in zarathustra. Since then, lowiths book has continued to gain recognition as one of the key texts in the german nietzsche reception, as well as a remarkable effort to reclaim the philosophers work from political misappropriation.
Friedrich nietzsche 18441900 was a german philosopher and cultural critic who published intensively in the 1870s and 1880s. Yet he remains a thinker of singular importance, a great opponent of hegel and kant, and the source of much that is powerful. And some even said that eternal recurrence was such a crucial part of nietzsche, 2 and central to his entire philosophy that without some discussion of the topic, they felt as. Faced with the prospect that every moment in ones life. Nietzsche, friedrich internet encyclopedia of philosophy. Nov 21, 2018 nietzsches idea of eternal recurrence invites us to consider how we would cope with such knowledge.
Nietzsches philosophy of the eternal recurrence of the. Blanqui is mentioned by albert lange in his geschichte des materialismus history of materialism, a book closely read by nietzsche. However, nietzsches main interest in the eternal recurrence is the theoretical one of how a person would come to terms with this doctrine. No one would really know or confirm if particular things. At the center of nietzsches philosophy is the idea of eternal return the ultimate embrace of responsibility that comes from accepting the consequences, good or bad, of ones willful action. Actually, the principal development of the teaching occurs in thus spoke zarathustra, a poetic work beyond compare. The concept of eternal recurrence, the idea that with infinite time and. The accounts of eternal recurrence and love of fate appeal to claims about the nature of the self, freedom, and responsibility. However there appears to have some unanswered questions related to exactness and liberation mokhsa.
One notable exception is found in the work of friedrich nietzsche 18441900, a 19thcentury german thinker who was known for his unconventional approach to philosophy. More than eighty years after his death, nietzsches writings and his career remain disquieting, disturbing, obscure. Nietzsche mentioned or expressed his philosophical views and opinions about the concept or notion of eternal return, or eternal recurrence of the same, i. Friedrich nietzsche 18441900 nietzsche was a german philosopher, essayist, and cultural critic. Paul loeb from puget sound visited my class with gary shapiro one time to defend this view. Nietzsches 1878 book, human, all too human, his inaugural assault on wagner and romantic metaphysics, hammers away at the word mitleid, considering it an instrument of weakness. The fact that nietzsche had access to this book in silsmaria in the summer of 1881 at the time of his conception of the eternal return is confirmed. The eternal recurrence of the same hardcover march 1, 1985 by martin heidegger author. In a sense, the eternal recurrence is a kind of litmus test for a potential overman. Eternal recurrence is nietzsches replacement for the last judgment. This is nietzsches doctrine of eternal recurrence, as depicted in the gay science and thus spoke zarathustra. The question in each and every thing, do you want this once more and innumerable times more.
In his groundbreaking book beyond good and evil, nietzsche tore down the notion of. In ecce homo1888, nietzsche wrote that he thought of the eternal return as the fundamental conception of thus spoke zarathustra. Nietzsche and the struggle against nihilism spiked. Nietzsches zarathustra is described in karl lowiths book on nietzsches philosophy of the eternal recurrence of the same 1978, 1997 as a parable in which all. At the center of nietzsches philosophy is the idea of eternal return the. Friedrich nietzsche stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Faced with the prospect that every moment in ones life will echo for eternity, only an overman would rejoice. We are taught how to discuss and debate, but not how to live.
My philosophy brings the triumphant idea of which all other modes of thought will ultimately perish. This author has also not found yet, any vedic reference on eternal recurrence. In making nietzsches eternal recurrence the theme of this book, gillespie has set himself a huge task. The power of the scene owes much, i believe, not only to the way it grows from the themes. Despite his thisworldliness, with his teaching of eternal recurrence, nietzsche no less than the christians preaches an immortality we shall all return, just as we are, again and again, forever that lacks any empirical warrant. The eternal recurrence my philosophy brings the triumphant idea of which all other modes of thought will ultimately perish.
Nietzsche was pretty invested in this question, which he called eternal recurrence, or eternal return. Not only is it one of the philosophers weakest and most unconvincing theses, it is the. Nietzsches zarathustra is described in karl lowiths book on nietzsches philosophy of the eternal recurrence of the same 1978, 1997 as a parable in which all knowledge is merely human creativity responding to new ways of dying. Dove maintains that one achieves nietzsche s ethical ideal if one is capable of affirming the eternal recurrence of ones life and of loving fate this is what nietzsche calls amor fati. In this knowing, willful repetition of their previous cycle, the couple echoes one of nietzsches most famous ideas. Time and personal identity in nietzsches theory of. Everything we have done or will do we will do over and over and over againforever.
How does eternal sunshine of the spotless mind illustrate nietzschean philosophies related. And some even said that eternal recurrence was such a crucial part of nietzsche, 2. Nietzsche, eternal recurrence, and the horror of existence core. Or how well disposed would you have to become to yourself and to life to crave nothing more fervently than this ultimate eternal confirmation and seal. The eternal return, suffering, and the affirmation. Countless books on nietzsche are published in dozens of languages each year, linking him to every imaginable zone of life and culture. It is clear that cohle recounts this idea in a pessimistic manner. In which of his books does nietzsche talk about eternal recurrence.
The university of omaha writes, what is there in this final, flat okay that feels so resonant and promising. Basically, nietzsches idea of eternal recurrence is simply a hypothesis of what he introduced in his work. Nietzsches idea of the eternal return, or eternal recurrence, is one of his most famous ideas, yet also one of the most misunderstood. At the center of nietzsche s philosophy is the idea of eternal return the ultimate embrace of responsibility that comes from accepting the consequences, good or bad, of ones willful action. Nietzsches discovery of the concept of eternal recurrence. If everything is caused, then, after every causal possibility has worked itself out, then the whole thing begins again, since there is no other option. Nietzsche celebrated this recurrence because of the power of belief in it to bring about a revaluation of values focused wholly on the value of ones.
I begin with a pointbypoint rejoinder to loebs critique of the thesis that the thought of eternal recurrence is a thoughtdrama. His writings on truth, morality, language, aesthetics, cultural theory, history, nihilism, power, consciousness, and the meaning of existence have exerted an enormous influence on western philosophy and intellectual history. Dove maintains that one achieves nietzsches ethical ideal if one is capable of affirming the eternal recurrence of ones life and of loving fate this is what nietzsche calls amor fati. Nietzsche s best 8 books an ebook to search the spirit of friedrich nietzsche edited by bill chapko contents editor notes introduction to nietzsche s life and writings the gay science ecce homo thus spoke zarathustra the dawn twilight of the idols the antichrist beyond good and evil genealogy of morals appendices a timeline biography. Friedrich nietzsche, german classical scholar, philosopher, and critic of culture, who became one of the most influential of all modern thinkers.
This is how nietzsches eternal recurrence seems to become correct. Such a misunderstanding often arises because there are two perspectives or ways to interpret this idea, leading some to confusion regarding exactly what nietzsche meant by it. Jul 02, 2017 the idea of eternal recurrence is the logical outcome of a totally deterministic universe. How does eternal sunshine of the spotless mind illustrate. This spectacle motivated nietzsche to work on the possibility of eternal recurrence or eternal return. Somewhat surprisingly given its prominence in the interpretation of nietzsches work, the motif of eternal recurrence occurs explicitly only a few times in his published books. Embedded in it is an urgent exhortation to calibrate our actions in such a way as to make their consequences bearable, livable with, in a. He published a easy, excellent book that argues that nietzsches theory of the eternal recurrence is a cosmological argument that was meant to be taken literally. This dialogue between nietzsche and vogt is clearly visible in the. Nietzsche the eternal recurrence of the same download ebook.
In which of his books does nietzsche talk about eternal. At the very end of the book, zarathustra overcomes his pity for the higher men. It was essentially an attempt to figure out an answer to the meaning of life, once and for all. The doctrine of eternal recurrence, the basic conception of thus spoke zarathustra, asks the question how well disposed would a person have to become to himself and to life to crave nothing more fervently than the infinite repetition, without alteration, of each and every moment. Like kaufman, nietzsche envisioned no way out of the traps set for us by our own natures or the nature of the. The critic harold bloom criticized thus spoke zarathustra in the western canon 1994, calling the book a gorgeous disaster and unreadable. Nietzsche presents a biologistic interpretation of the will to power as life.
Much of the work deals with ideas such as the eternal recurrence of the same, the parable on the death of god, and the prophecy of the ubermensch, which were first introduced in the gay science. Nietzsche and redemption steven gambardella medium. It is by no means an original idea, with variants of eternal recurrence appearing in both egyptian and mayan mythology, and in the work of kierkegaard. Eternal return also known as eternal recurrence is a theory that the universe and all existence and energy has been recurring, and will continue to recur, in a selfsimilar form an infinite number of times across infinite time or space. He first brought it up in his book the gay science, and returned to explore it more fully in thus spoke zarathustra. A book for all and none is a philosophical novel by german philosopher friedrich nietzsche, composed in four parts written and published between 1883 and 1885. The title comes from an unnerving passage in ecce homo, nietzsches autobiographical book of 1888, which was completed a couple of months before he descended into insanity, at the age of. Nietzsche himself considered zarathustra to be his magnum opus. The eternal return theory says youre not the first you to. For lowith, the centerpiece of nietzsches thought is the doctrine of eternal recurrence, a notion which lowith, unlike. History of materialism, a book closely read by nietzsche. The title of this book is nietzsches philosophy of the eternal recurrence of the same and it was written by karl lowith, j.
Eternal recurrence the gay science is one of nietzsches most personal works, collecting not only his philosophical reflections but also a number of poems, aphorisms, and songs. Nietzsches idea of eternal recurrence invites us to consider how we would cope with such knowledge. Eternal recurrence in the oxford handbook of nietzsche. Mar 06, 2019 nietzsche mentioned or expressed his philosophical views and opinions about the concept or notion of eternal return, or eternal recurrence of the same, i.
Time and personal identity in nietzsches theory of eternal recurrence scott jenkins university of kansas abstract friedrich nietzsches theory of eternal recurrence is an essential part of his mature philosophy, but the theorys metaphysical commitments and practical implications are both obscure. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Click download or read online button to get nietzsche the eternal recurrence of the same book now. Eternal recurrence revisited issue 7 philosophy now. Eternal recurrence is nietzsche s replacement for the last judgment. Nietzsches best 8 books an ebook to search the spirit of friedrich nietzsche edited by bill chapko contents editor notes introduction to nietzsches life and writings the gay science ecce homo thus spoke zarathustra the dawn twilight of the idols the antichrist beyond good and evil genealogy of morals appendices a timeline biography. The eternal recurrence of the same as want to read.
Eternal recurrence of the same events also known as eternal return is one of nietzsches more notable ideas. Time and personal identity in nietzsches theory of eternal recurrence scott jenkins university of kansas abstract friedrich nietzsches theory of eternal recurrence is. I begin with a pointbypoint rejoinder to loebs critique of the thesis that the thought of eternal recurrence is a thoughtdrama revealed through zarathustras thoughts and actions. The idea of eternal recurrence is the logical outcome of a totally deterministic universe. One of nietzsches most famous ideas is that of eternal recurrence, which appears in the penultimate section of his book the gay science. Harvey lomax on the love of eternity dedicated to professor hansgeorg gadamer on his 100th birthday. Heideggers critique of nietzsche as the nihilistic peak of the modern project to conquer nature could seem to suggest that the latter thinker argued for the validity of the eternal recurrence in metaphysical treatises. The eternal recurrence is also mentioned in passing by the devil in part four, book xi, chapter 9 of dostoevskys the brothers karamazov, which is another possible source that nietzsche may have been drawing upon. His attempts to unmask the motives that underlie traditional western religion, morality, and philosophy deeply affected generations of intellects. The eternal recurrence of the same martin heidegger on. Having read my book, gorfu contra nietzsche, 1 some had commented that a very important dimension of nietzsches philosophy had been left out.
1385 872 1176 1452 999 520 1610 1398 1254 1580 955 687 899 911 1611 417 1089 1104 706 1376 263 325 1163 347 1139 18 1020 1456 170 1321 496 1264 1302 15 1019 961 201